I wrote recently in the Boston Globe about the removal of the traffic rotary in front of the Sagamore Bridge leading to Cape Cod and argued that the hoped-for reductions in traffic were likely to be minimal. Here’s an excerpt from an email I received from Thomas Cahir that reinforces my view on the traffic problem but points out something important I should have mentioned:
I read with interest your op/ed piece relative to the elimination of the Sagamore Rotary. I have lived in the Town of Bourne on Cape Cod for fifty years. I also served in the Massachusetts Legislature representing four upper Cape communities for fourteen years. During my entire tenure in the Massachusetts House, I served on the Joint Transportation Committee — six years as Vice-Chairman and two as Chairman.
As you may know, Sagamore is a village within my home town of Bourne. Therefore, the Rotary is an issue very close to my heart. I have stood on that Rotary during hundreds of different weekends throughout the years in an effort to get a better understanding of related issues and concerns. I sponsored the legislation authorizing the funding for the planning, design and construction of the recently completed project. I wanted to tell you all of this to let you know that over the course of the last fifteen years, I have heard every conceivable suggestion, plan, idea, etc. as to how to fix the most significant traffic hazard in Southeastern Massachusetts.
As a co-sponsor of the legislation creating the Cape Cod Commission (a regional land use planning agency) I strongly consider the Cape’s quality of life in every public decision that I make. Cape Cod is indeed a very special place, and we all must do whatever we can to protect and preserve it. The issues you raise are valid. Traffic congestion, in my opinion, has become the #1 issue of concern to the Barnstable County citizenry. I have long promoted efforts to improve and expand mobility options to the Cape.
However, my main purpose in responding to your thoughts is a particular comment that you made. You mention that "one possibility is that the new bottleneck will be just as bad as the Sagamore Rotary. In that case, the project accomplishes nothing.” For many years, certain folks who are justifiably concerned about the inordinate growth we have recently experienced on the Cape, believed that the sole purpose for eliminating the Rotary was to make it easier for people to get on and off Cape Cod.
Of course with the elimination of an obsolete, seventy year old traffic configuration intended to accommodate 30% of the traffic volumes that it now must handle, lengthy present day queuing will be reduced. However, it is important to remember that there remain only four ten foot lanes of highway (Bourne & Sagamore Bridges) that have to accommodate every vehicle that comes onto or leaves the Cape.
In addition, when I have been asked over the years to identify the benefits that will be realized upon completion of the project, I have been consistent in my opinion that ease of getting on and off Cape Cod is fourth or fifth on the list. Clearly, the main benefit is public safety. The Sagamore Rotary has been the leading traffic accident intersection in Barnstable County for many years. With its elimination, the area will become much safer, which is not insignificant. Another major benefit is that the new intersection will allow the residents of Sagamore Beach to safely access other parts of our town. For years, the 4000 plus residents have been extraordinarily inconvenienced when trying to get out of their village. Enhanced access to area businesses and air quality improvement are other benefits worthy of note.



Podcast RSS Feed
Full EconTalk Text





{ 7 comments }
Although basic economics tells us that the roads will still be congested(*), the thing nobody seems to have mentioned yet is that MORE PEOPLE will be able to get to and from Cape Cod with the same amount of "congestion".
(*) Actually, basic economics doesn't even tell us that, because otherwise ALL free roads would be congested and that is clearly not the case. All we can really say is that given reasonable assumptions about the popularity of Cape Cod (i.e. the demand for road capacity) then the road will still be congested.
Holy crap, a *smart* politician who not only thinks about what he does, but even pays attention to what other people are saying about it!
I miss living on the East coast.
Kudos for publishing this letter. It speaks to your intellectual honesty, something sometimes in short supply in this day and age.
I have such blog, that about traveling, and travels, here it is: Discount travels blog – information about travel guide, cheap flights, travel guidance, budget travel, travel, uk travel blog, airfare, hotels.
Sorry for terrible English, hello from belorussia
I have commuted for years and with the rotaries traffic could be brutal even when it was far from tourist season.
cool article really super cool
Did you know? – Oman is one of the most stable, safe and peaceful countries in the Arabian Gulf – as rated by the 2007 Global Peace Index. Oman is also the 22nd most peaceful country in the world.
I recommend to visit the sultanate.