Hayeku on the state of the union

by Russ Roberts on January 27, 2010

in Hayeku,Uncategorized

A haiku is a three line poem. The first line has five syllables. The second line has seven. The third line has five.

A hayeku (HT: Ike Pigott for the name and the encouragement) is a haiku from an Hayekian perspective. Here’s one to get you started:

Why do we pretend

That “mandatory” spending

Is mandatory?

View Comments    Share Share    Print Print    Email Email

  • hjbdfsjlvhbfv
    Tax cuts here and there,
    but still a lot of spending.
    How could that go wrong?
  • LowcountryJoe
    Socialism's here!
    In long run, we all succumb.
    We're all muir-geos now.
  • vidyohs
    Cool! Salute!
  • Sarkozy's reform?
    Add morals to our markets!
    But just whose morals??
  • Obama has plan
    chess pieces to be arranged
    invisible 'cuffs
  • I am not impressed.
    The Cylons had a plan too.
    See how that worked out? ;)
  • griswomw
    Ye of little faith
    Cylons just robot cyborgs
    O' says "you’ve got me!"
  • I'm really afraid
    That the SOTU will display
    The Fatal Conceit
  • Matt
    How about a limerick?
    There once was man from Sachs
    Who frittered away our stacks.
    He bailed out AIG
    Wall Street applauded with glee
    And for that, his bags we must pack
  • ClayBarham
    The earliest American settlers found what worked was the ability of each individual to think, imagine, create, build and change the environment with their sweat, even disturbing the established and accepted way things are done without fear of punishment. That was America, and what set her apart from all other nations, as cited in Save Pebble Droppers & Prosperity at Amazon and claysamerica.com. Individual freedom caused local government, close to the governed within a day’s horseback ride. The governed ruled, and they could change government in Town Halls, voting or by vigilante movements, much like the Tea Party movement today. It is our tradition. Claysamerica.com
  • Where's Muirgeo?
    Can't you hear him dub Krugman
    Poet Laureate?
  • nonanny
    About the word "fair"
    Life and Thought are much clearer
    When no longer said.
  • Keynes bizarre theory:
    "Animal Sentiments" is
    just not up to it.
  • piefarmer
    Economy down?
    Free the individuals
    And watch the pie grow!
  • Economy falls
    Progressives rush to proclaim
    It is not our fault
  • dislikedisqus
    Garden of Eden?
    Or just a big post office?
    Redistribution.
  • MicroNomics
    Magic wands appear

    POTUS SCOTUS Congress grab

    Poof...Disney order

    (HT: Tinkerbelle)
  • Economiser
    There once was a man named Keynes
    Who said, "Assemble the mightiest brains!
    Let them control and command;
    Boost aggregate demand!"
    In his debt, society remains.

    What, wrong format?
  • yetanotherdave
    Oh, terribly sorry, this is haiku.

    Limerick is down the hall, third door on the left...
  • Limericker
    There once was a woman from Venus
    who's body was shaped like a...

    nevermind
  • Thirty-six years past,
    Hayek receives the Nobel
    that Mises deserved.
  • We can't afford not to,

    While we can't afford to, but

    We can't afford not to.
  • baltimorepete
    Presidential needs:
    Keywords, political talk,
    Catchy rhetoric.
  • Kevin S.
    I don't have a job
    The free market is to blame
    More central planning

    /Sarcasm off
  • Pingry
    Vapid Austrians
    Liquidate malinvestment
    The innocent lose

    Too low for too long
    Is the ad nauseum claim
    but no evidence

    A misguided graph
    And Don claims unsound money
    Wise up Mr. White

    Ron Paul end the Fed
    A hard money populist
    Here comes inflation

    What we really need
    Central bank independence
    Banish the gold bugs

    Gold fetishism
    But no intrinsic value
    Barbarous relic

    Marginalism
    But not according to Marx
    Or the gold people

    Cluster of errors
    Please stop making me laugh hard
    I do real econ

    Austrian macro
    Tells you what you want to hear
    And too simplistic

    Friedman called it out
    Austrian business cycle
    With plucking model

    But Friedman was wrong
    With the fixed money growth rule
    Velocity shifts

    Still admire him
    Longrun Phillips Curve
    He denounced with Phelps

    Let us not forget
    His Nonparametric stat
    Great statistician

    Most importantly
    Dominated Westmoreland
    Helped to end the draft


    --Pingry
  • sandre
    Pingry is angry
    His hero is a zero
    Bernanke panky
  • baltimorepete
    You're haiku is long
    And very condescending
    Pingry hit-and-run
  • yetanotherdave
    Epic, not haiku,
    loses elegance with length
    in spite of the form
  • David
    Hail the Oracle,
    Blowing bubbles with such skill.
    Wait, they've popped! Oh dear.
  • SheetWise
    Jeopardy challenge:
    Obama is the answer -
    What was the question?
  • yetanotherdave
    What unqualified
    person can get elected
    and screw it all up?
  • yetanotherdave
    Tonight we will see
    an arrogant president
    blame it all on Bush
  • Tiptree
    Chaotic markets
    hide the emerging order
    new wealth from old

    Men plan and plans fail
    Unexpected consequence?
    Hayek knew better
  • For you to debate
    knowledge in society
    you would need knowledge
  • vidyohs
    That's good.
  • Decisions should be
    based on info and knowledge
    not populism
  • yetanotherdave
    The union is not strong
    It will not be for long
    And everything obama does
    is wrong, wrong, wrong



    oops! wrong form!
  • yetanotherdave
    PS - you have to say that one with Bart Simpson's voice...
  • kurlos
    The Left and Right frown.

    "It is not normal to shrug.

    Assert your truth, freak!"
  • yetanotherdave
    The curious task
    of economists is to
    show that Keynes was wrong
  • yetanotherdave
    Central planners can't
    better individuals
    running the economy
  • indianajim
    Obamanomics, Obamacare;
    Deficits, taxes, deficits deficits, taxes.
    Puke.
  • kevindv
    Markets evolve from
    Human action not human
    Design says Hayek.
  • yetanotherdave
    Hayek understood
    what Keynesians just cannot:
    let people be free
  • yetanotherdave
    So much damage done
    by the followers of Keynes.
    Hayek was more wise
  • All I really want
    Not unemployment, no dole
    Honest income please
  • indianajim
    Paradox of Thrift
    or Hayekian Triangle?
    Keynes if full of sh**!
  • rodet
    Attempt to explain
    voter sentiment will not
    include "over reach"
  • BoscoH
    Housing will cost less
    Hail Freddy! (Hayek, not MAC)
    Better re-fi now.
  • BoscoH
    Hayeku battle.
    Ike Pigott versus Bosco.
    It's totally on!
  • Challenge accepted.
    But I'm no economist,
    just a crack wordsmith.
  • BoscoH
    Keynes enables us
    to pull cash out of our @$$.
    Cain killed Abel. Hmmmm.
  • anomdebus
    Successful thieves they
    Agree on turf boundaries.
    Territory safe.
  • anomdebus
    Just as a matter of record, this was a direct response to the original haiku.
  • BoscoH
    Need more stimulus!
    Promotes growth in recession.
    Like Joe Biden's hair.
  • BoscoH
    Cynics obstruct me.
    Enemies of hope and change.
    "O-ba-ma." Say it.
  • BoscoH
    Health care in shambles.
    How can the people get by?
    One day at a time.
  • "Good evening, Congress,
    and my fellow Socialists."
    Teleprompter FAIL!
  • yetanotherdave
    I hope that tonight
    the teleprompter does fail.
    Wouldn't that be fun?

  • Mike M.
    In long run we're dead
    Yesterday's long run today
    Pass burden to kids
  • Mike M.
    High time preference brings
    Government Stimulus plan
    Skews order of goods

    Love easy credit!
    Everything is smooth sailing
    Whoops, maybe it's not?
  • igorbivor
    Those with the power
    To set government budgets
    Display no restraint
  • matt
    So far it looks like
    Economists like Hayek
    Write bad haikus
  • russroberts
    Critics of Hayek
    Miss chance to learn econ and
    Can't count syllables
  • I wish there were a way to "Like" a comment more than once.
  • matt
    Where was Hayek criticized?
    Only your poetry was
    And I'm happy you can count
    Even if you cannot read

    Wait... what are the rules?
  • russroberts
    The first line should have five syllables.
    The second line should have seven syllables.
    The third line should have five syllables.
  • BoscoH
    So centrally planned.
    Five seven five formula.
    Hayek might not like.

    :-)
  • As Hayek did know,
    Rules by social convention,
    Equate not to force.
  • In a Keynes Haiku,
    Syllables can be nonsense.
    Just so there's enough.
  • Keynesian Haiku
    is in even less demand.
    They have to fake it.
  • Emergent Order
    Coordination without
    planning from above
  • We need stimulus
    The same way a deaf person
    Needs a Bose system.
  • udctrox
    Correction! Not in the same way...a bose system will not harm a deaf person!
  • It does if he is forced at gunpoint to pay for it.
  • State of the Union?
    Applause lines planned in advance
    Are not emergent.
  • vidyohs
    Vote your voice for change
    Defeat Obama we must
    Drain corrupt cess pool
  • Aggregate demand:
    It's economics without
    Imagination
  • Brilliant! ;-)
  • hylarides
    How little we know
    how much we think that we know
    Ignorance is bliss
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: