≡ Menu

Here’s a letter to the Sun Chronicle.

Editor:

Desmond Lachman justly criticizes President Trump’s tariffs and the administration’s failure to reduce the gargantuan budget deficit (“Trump’s failed import tariff policy added to inflation,” November 13). But contrary to Mr. Lachman’s claim, it’s unclear that a restoration of fiscal prudence would reduce U.S. trade deficits. Perhaps the opposite would occur.

Obviously, every dollar that foreigners lend to the U.S. government is a dollar that foreigners don’t spend on U.S. exports and, thus, a dollar added to the U.S. trade deficit. But foreigners can and do invest in the U.S. in ways other than extending credit to our spendthrift government. It’s quite possible that, if Congress and the administration restored fiscal discipline to Washington, our economy’s investment climate would improve so much that global investors would increase their private-sector investments in America by enough to cause U.S. trade deficits to swell – an outcome that, despite Mr. Trump’s stubborn insistence otherwise, would be cause for America to celebrate.

Sincerely,
Donald J. Boudreaux
Professor of Economics
and
Martha and Nelson Getchell Chair for the Study of Free Market Capitalism at the Mercatus Center
George Mason University
Fairfax, VA 22030

{ 0 comments }

Some Links

These letters in today’s Wall Street Journal – one of which is written by GMU Econ alum Dave Hebert – expose the harmful unseriousness of the Trump administration’s trade team:

After reading U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer’s letter, I’m scratching my head as to what the Trump administration believes the effect of tariffs are (“The Success of President Trump’s Trade Policy,” Nov. 16). The president says that tariffs are a tool in the effort to revitalize U.S. manufacturing. They do so by protecting U.S. firms from the competition of cheaper imports. Adding tariffs to the price of imports makes U.S. manufactured products more competitive within U.S. markets, and consumers can be expected to reallocate their expenditures accordingly.

But Mr. Greer says that only a fraction of the cost of tariffs is passed on to consumers. If so, why would consumers shift more purchases to American-made products, and how is U.S. manufacturing helped? Mr. Greer is making a claim irreconcilable with that of his boss. Which administration position am I supposed to believe?

Theodore A. Gebhard
Zionsville, Ind.
Mr. Gebhard was a senior economist with the International Trade Administration.

Mr. Greer deserves credit for his courage. In citing Caroline Freund’s paper which found that foreign exporters are absorbing “roughly 40-50% of the 2025 US tariff increases,” he recognizes that Americans have absorbed the remaining 50% to 60%. Mr. Greer’s other source, Preston Caldwell, agrees that “U.S. firms are still footing most of the tariff bill.”

Most other studies find that Americans, consumers and firms combined, are paying upwards of 90%. The Congressional Budget Office’s February report, written during a Republican Congress, finds that “foreign exporters will absorb 5% of the cost of tariffs,” leaving 95% to Americans. Pablo Fajgelbaum and Amit Khandelwal estimate that Americans absorb 90% of the tariffs. The Richmond Fed finds that Americans are paying near 100% of the tariffs.

The Trump administration promised that foreigners would pay all of the tariffs. Now, their top trade official concedes that Americans are paying, at a minimum, half of the tariffs. Voters took those higher prices and costs into account on Nov. 3.

David Hebert
American Inst. for Economic Research

Desmond Lachman surveys Trump’s harmful obsession with tariffing punitively taxing Americans’ purchases of imports. A slice:

The essential point is that a tariff is basically a tax paid by the importers. Importers might initially absorb some of that tax in terms of lower profit margins. However, in time they tend to pass most of the tax on to consumers. In addition, domestic producers who compete with imports can raise their own prices, and firms that rely on imported parts or materials face higher costs. This is especially true for industries that use aluminum and steel imports.

Ron Mau and Tucker Smith with the Dallas Fed estimated that tariff collections added nearly a full percentage point (0.8%) to the 12-month core PCE inflation rate.

Warren Coats is understandably critical of Oren Cass and the ‘New Right.’ Two slices:

Contrary to Reagan’s free-trade views that markets will allocate resources to the greatest benefit of all involved, the New Right “believes that a strong manufacturing sector on these shores provides the foundation for national power, technological innovation and stable communities — so the government should use tariffs and subsidies to support an industrial base that the market, as well as foreign powers, might otherwise undermine.” Trump’s use of tariffs generally had little to do with creating a level playing field that would maximize global income. Rather they reflected his bully approach for seeking other objectives. The fact is that US manufacturing output last year was virtually the same as it was at the end of 2001 when China entered the World Trade Organization. However, employment in manufacturing has fallen because of increased labor productivity, surely a good thing. And as our economy is fully employed, the reduced manufacturing workers have found jobs elsewhere.

…..

But Cass’s most obnoxious misrepresentation of Reagan Republicans’ views has to do with the role of virtue and its sources. Cass claims that: “The Reaganites believe strongly that liberty is the most important end unto itself. People with the liberty to make their own choices can maximize their own well-being, in this thinking, and a nation focused on protecting that liberty will enjoy the greatest freedom and prosperity as a result… The New Right finds this absurd. Liberty cannot mean only license to do what one wants… Between the extremes of moral relativism and oppressive conformity lies an enormous expanse in which the state can and should establish priorities, including strong families and stable communities.”

There is no way Cass is not aware of the importance Reagan Republicans put on virtue and of its development in the private sector. This is what the discussion of “fusionism” was all about. “Not all Freedom Conservatives see our project in explicitly fusionist terms, as a formal philosophical synthesis of freedom and order, liberty and virtue. But all FreeCons do believe that unless we take virtue seriously, demand it of our leaders, and transmit it to future generations, the American experiment in self-government will not be sustainable.”

Kenneth Costello runs us through some economics of data-center development.

Wall Street Journal columnist Jason Riley asks: “If ‘systemic racism’ is real, how did Scott Colom win?” A slice:

A recent Journal editorial on the election of Scott Colom, who will become Mississippi’s first black U.S. senator since Reconstruction and its first Democratic senator in 38 years, ended by asking: “Why won’t Democrats celebrate America’s manifest racial progress?”

It’s a question many reasonable people have been asking at least since Barack Obama won the presidency nearly 20 years ago. Mr. Obama not only claimed the popular vote twice in what remains a majority-white country, he won some of the palest states—Iowa, Wisconsin, Vermont, Maine, Ohio, New Hampshire. Even in Southern states he lost, such as Georgia, Texas and South Carolina, Mr. Obama garnered more white support than John Kerry in 2004 and Al Gore in 2000.

What makes Mr. Colom’s victory especially noteworthy is that Mississippi played an important role in the history of black civil rights, albeit for all the wrong reasons. Martin Luther King Jr. called it “the most difficult state in the United States in race relations.” It is where Medgar Evers, an NAACP official and Army veteran, was gunned down in 1963 for trying to organize black voters. It was the home of Fannie Lou Hamer, who challenged the seating of Mississippi’s all-white delegation at the 1964 Democratic National Convention. It’s where 14-year-old Emmett Till was abducted and killed by a group of white men in 1955, an event that gained wide media attention in the North and energized the civil-rights movement.

Liberals discuss voter suppression as if we were still living in the Eisenhower era, but in 2012 blacks turned out to vote at higher rates than whites. Democrats likewise maintain that blacks must be segregated in racially gerrymandered districts to ensure the election of black lawmakers. Yet as far back as 1982, five black candidates from mostly white districts won seats in the North Carolina Legislature. In more recent decades, both parties have elected black congressional candidates from majority-white districts, including Democrats Alan Wheat of Missouri and Sanford Bishop of Georgia and Republicans Gary Franks of Connecticut, Allen West of Florida and Mia Love of Utah. The Brookings Institution reports that in the current Congress, “only eight out of the 61 Black House members were elected from majority-Black districts.”

Most people cheer these political developments in a nation with our ugly history of black oppression, yet many liberals do so only reluctantly, while others pretend that the country is as antiblack ever. Voter ID laws are “Jim Crow in the 21st century,” according to Joe Biden. Systemic racism is “the air we breathe,” Pete Buttigieg claims. Self-styled antiracist activist Ibram X. Kendi insists that “to grow up in America is to grow up, and for racist ideas to constantly be rained on your head and you have no umbrella. And you don’t even know that you’re wet with those racist ideas, because the racist ideas themselves cause you to imagine that you’re dry.”

Despite growing evidence to the contrary, you’re expected to believe that white racism continues to be the country’s defining feature. Liberals traffic in racial resentment to advance an agenda that has far more to do with maintaining their own influence and relevance than with addressing social inequality. Democrats spend a lot of time arguing that black people can’t get ahead due to racism, which make blacks who do succeed a threat. Hence the eagerness to play down or ignore obvious progress. If support for black candidates has increased this year, you’re told, it isn’t because racial tensions have subsided. Rather, it’s because the GOP’s voter suppression efforts didn’t work as planned. Heads they win, tails you lose.

Jacob Sullum reports that “Trump says he welcomes foreign students. His policies tell a different story.”

GMU Econ alum Dominic Pino tweets:

You’ll never believe it, but Spain did rent controls and now there’s a housing shortage.

{ 0 comments }

Quotation of the Day…

… is from page 154 of the 2019 Mercatus Center edition of my emeritus GMU Econ colleague Richard Wagner’s excellent 1998 book, To Promote the General Welfare:

Any creation of an entitlement or sheltered status concomitantly entails either a limitation on the ability of someone else to earn a livelihood or a taking of some of the results of previous effort.

DBx: Indeed so.

For example, protectionists are forever patting themselves on their backs for what they take to be their magnanimous assistance to protected workers and firm-owners. Yet they never scold themselves for their thoughtless disregard not only of consumers who must pay higher prices, but also of the workers and firms who, as a result of this faux magnanimity, necessarily lose particular jobs and economic opportunities.

{ 0 comments }

Some Links

My Mercatus Center colleague (and former student) Liya Palagashvili, and her co-author Benjamin Glasner, explain – in the pages of the Wall Street Journal – that “gig work is good work.” Two slices:

A Mercatus Center survey of nearly 3,000 Instacart workers shows how households are using flexible work to weather the affordability crisis. It is the first independent survey of the platform’s shoppers, who pick up and deliver customer orders. Their answers don’t support the stereotype that gig workers can’t find traditional employment. Instead, shoppers largely describe how gig income, layered on top of other jobs and side hustles, helps them keep pace with rising prices.

More than 80% of Instacart shoppers average less than 10 hours a week on the platform. The typical shopper puts in about two hours a week and has another job. But the supplemental income is hardly incidental. More than a third say losing it would create financial hardship or prevent them from covering expenses.

When prices rise, a household responds by cutting back or earning more. For many Instacart shoppers, gig work is how they earn more. The extra income mostly goes to food and housing, and more shoppers use the money for debt payments than for entertainment.

Many workers turn to gig work for its flexibility. Nearly 9 in 10 Instacart shoppers say the platform lets them work hours that a traditional job wouldn’t. That flexibility is crucial for balancing family obligations and school or health demands.

About 45% of women with children who don’t hold a traditional job said those pressures made regular employment hard to manage. For some mothers, flexibility isn’t a perk. It is what makes paid work possible. Meantime, older shoppers are using gig work to stretch retirement income.

These financial choices illustrate a tension in labor policy. We should care about the pay and benefits that come with a job. But we also need to ask whether people can access work that fits their individual needs. Asked what they would do without Instacart, shoppers’ most common answer was simple: another gig. Most said they wouldn’t even look for a job with regular hours.

…..

A side gig won’t solve every financial problem, let alone reverse the mistakes that have made daily life so expensive. But for millions of people, it is the affordability plan that keeps a squeeze from becoming a crisis.

The Washington Post‘s Dominic Pino (a GMU Econ alum) makes a strong case against export controls. Two slices:

But the failure of export controls is an old story. The strategy has usually been ineffective for commercial products, due to both government ineptitude and basic economics.

Export controls are based on the theory that supersmart Washington planners can manage adversaries’ economies by strategically denying them access to key products. The problem is that export controls are ultimately imposed by politicians, who specialize in political calculations, not strategic ones.

Go back to the 1990s, when satellites were the key strategic technology of the future. The United States had export controls on China, which were enforced … selectively. “You asked me to support your economic package; I did,” Hughes Electronics CEO C. Michael Armstrong wrote in a 1993 letter to President Bill Clinton. Armstrong wanted a waiver to allow Hughes to sell satellite technology in China, because without it, “potentially thousands of California people could lose their jobs.” Hughes got its way.

You might say the problem is having ethically malleable presidents like Clinton or Trump in power. But export controls were waived under George H.W. Bush, too. The U.S. imposed restrictions on China on June 5, 1989, after the Tiananmen Square massacre. Just a month later, it waived them to allow Boeing to sell Beijing aircraft with navigation systems capable of military usage.

…..

Proponents of export controls can’t decide on their story. When Chinese companies export vital goods such as rare earth minerals to the U.S., that’s genius economic warfare to make Americans reliant on their products. But when U.S. companies export vital goods such as AI chips to China, that’s feeding the adversary’s economy. The case for export controls degenerates into a case for autarky, as trade in either direction is treated as a security threat.

Export controls are fundamentally based on hubris. American bureaucrats can’t manage the American economy. Why would anyone expect them to be able to manage foreign ones?

Also writing insightfully about export controls is Reason‘s Tosin Akintola.

GMU Econ alum David Hebert, and my intrepid Mercatus center colleague, Veronique de Rugy, tell what Trump’s tariffs punitive taxes on Americans’ purchases of imports have wrought. A slice:

Businesses looking to expand also paid the tariff bill. About half of what America imports is capital equipment and intermediate goods used to make other products, so a tariff on imports also works as a tax on investment. Analysis from the American Enterprise Institute found that the IEEPA tariffs raised the effective tax rate on new business investment from 9.5 percent to 17.3 percent. This almost 8-point increase was more than enough to erase the investment tax cuts in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act.

Then there are the raw materials that American manufacturers need to produce their incredible output. Steel and aluminum tariffs were sold as a lifeline to heavy industry. We were told that as we bolstered domestic production of these critical materials, their prices would come down. Instead, producer prices for steel have risen 28 percent from September 2025 to September 2026. Aluminum mill shapes rose 25 percent over the same period. Hot-rolled steel, crucial for most American manufacturing, reached $1,430 per ton. It was $726 on January 20, 2025. In their February report, the Institute for Supply Management included a quote from a respondent saying, “Today, American produced commodities like steel and aluminum are the highest priced in the world, by far. Hence, the Section 232 tariff policy is having the exact opposite effect of their intention on an American manufacturer like us: It is raising prices while lowering demand and profitability.” Back then, hot-rolled steel was still under $1,000 per ton. Every single American manufacturer that uses steel and aluminum is paying more for materials because of the tariffs.

Hendrik Brakel and Daniel Dorman call for an end to harmful U.S.-Canada trade hostilities. A slice:

It is now evident that tariffs were a liability in an election in which the cost of living was the top issue. Polling by Ipsos shows that 81 percent of Americans say that tariffs increase the cost of goods they buy. (Try to find another issue that 81 percent of Americans agree on.) Fifty-seven percent of Americans oppose the tariffs on Canada, including 87 percent of Democrats and 64 percent of independents.

In September, a survey from the Cato Institute/Morning Consult found that 75 percent said tariffs would be important to their vote in the midterm elections. A solid majority said the tariffs are a tax on Americans (57 percent) and believe they have weakened the U.S. economy (53 percent). That is why Democrats ran ads against tariffs in New Hampshire, Michigan, Georgia, and Pennsylvania.

The Washington Post‘s Editorial Board explains that ‘pro-labor’ arrangements (so-called), unable to repeal the laws of economics, are really anti-labor policies.. A slice:

Germany’s system of “codetermination” can make adjustment more difficult. Employees at large companies elect representatives to supervisory boards, and works councils have extensive rights over workplace decisions. These arrangements give incumbent workers considerable power to defend existing benefits even when competitive conditions change.

Markets impose a discipline that bargaining cannot wish away. Consumers have no obligation to pay extra for German cars, and capital has no obligation to remain in Germany. If factories cannot justify higher costs through greater productivity or innovation, investment will go elsewhere.

The union at Mercedes can keep insisting on a 35-hour week. It cannot insist that the next Mercedes be built in Germany.

The Editorial Board of the Wall Street Journal justly lambasts Virginia Gov. Abigail Spanberger for being a pawn of the so-called “teachers” unions – and, as such, an obstacle to better K-12 education for young Virginians. A slice:

It shouldn’t be controversial for Virginia children to take advantage of the new federal program for K-12 education expenses, as students in 31 states will do. But Democratic Gov. Abigail Spanberger is telling them no.

In a particular sting, Virginia families thought they were in. Republican Gov. Glenn Youngkin signed the state up for the program, which grants federal tax credits for donations to scholarships, before he left office in January. But to complete the process to join, states must submit a list of eligible scholarship-granting organizations (SGOs) to the U.S. Treasury, which they couldn’t do until October.

Last month the state teachers union urged Gov. Spanberger not to submit the list. On Friday her office told the Washington Post she is following the union’s orders.

What a regrettable pass on federal money that could help students pay for private school, tutoring and more. Taxpayers can get a federal credit up to $1,700, or $3,400 for married couples, for donating to SGOs. But students can get scholarships only in states that opt in.

About 1.4 million students are eligible in Virginia, and 10% of eligible state donors participating could yield $731 million, Patrick Graff of the American Federation for Children has estimated. That Virginia money could now flow to students in the states that have said yes.

The Spanberger administration “does not believe this program would benefit students in public schools,” a spokesperson told the Post. But Democratic Governors Michelle Lujan Grisham of New Mexico and Kathy Hochul of New York both cited the benefit for public school students as they opted in recently.

Education writer Chad Aldeman said he was working to start an SGO to help students in high-poverty public schools in Virginia access tutoring. “We can’t do that now,” he wrote.

[DBx: Is there an interest group in the U.S. that’s more venal, corrupt, destructive, and powerful than “teachers” unions? I think not. The combination of this monstrous lobby of grifters and frauds with a K-12 government “education” system that no one in his or her right mind would design as a reliable means of educating children is a stain – and a growing strain – upon the United States.]

Daniel Hannan decries the lingering ill-consequences of the covidian lockdowns.

{ 0 comments }

Quotation of the Day…

… is from page 65 of GMU Econ alums Scott Burns’s and Caleb Fuller’s forthcoming (in February 2027) book, Trade Wars: Why Freedom Trumps Tariffs:

The tariffs of the late nineteenth century didn’t accelerate America’s industrialization and growth. If anything, the evidence suggests they dampened it. As economist Douglas Irwin notes, non-tradable sectors experienced faster growth than tradable sectors during the era, implying that tariffs didn’t do much to stimulate domestic production or kickstart industrialization. Moreover, many of the manufacturing industries that protectionists claim rose to prominence during the 1800s actually arose in the free-trade antebellum era, not the more protectionist postbellum era. The main industries that tariffs stimulated in the postbellum era were lobbying and privilege-seeking in Washington, DC, as special interest groups flocked to the capital to campaign for tariffs on foreign competitors.

{ 0 comments }

Some Links

GMU Econ alum Adam Michel shares, in the Washington Post, some wise warnings about the itch to soak the rich. A slice:

Despite regular reminders that wealth taxes are generally unpopular, such measures always seem in vogue. California wealth-tax advocates are already plotting a 2028 do-over, and with large majorities in Congress after January, Democrats are likely to push for similar proposals federally. Economists like me spend much of our time explaining how wealth taxes hurt employers, drive out investment and raise little revenue. But the absurd things people do to avoid them can be even more revealing.

France repealed its annual net wealth tax in 2017 after the prime minister concluded that it had driven 10,000 people with 35 billion euros’ ($39.3 billion) worth of assets out of the country. The exodus shrank the overall tax base and caused the government to lose revenue, according to one analysis. California didn’t even need to pass its version to get the same result. Because the measure was based on where a billionaire lived on Jan. 1, nearly 30 percent of the projected wealth tax base left before the vote, and the income taxes those people would have paid left with them.

Wall Street Journal columnist Allysia Finley reports on some ill-consequences of hubristic overreach. A slice:

Thanks to this month’s GOP rout, Democrats are well-positioned to capture a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate in 2028. If they also keep the House and win the presidency, it will be no-holds-barred for progressives. Mr. Trump’s hard-won tax, Medicaid and student-loan reforms could be reversed in a heartbeat. A wealth tax is a real possibility.

Democrats will impose California’s loosey-goosey election rules nationwide. The conservative Supreme Court majority would be in jeopardy too. All because Mr. Trump overshot on tariffs, immigration and so much more. Pride goeth before the fall.

GMU Econ alum Romina Boccia warns that “Bernie Sanders would make Social Security bigger and America poorer.”

Jarrett Dieterle and Santiago Vidal Calvo decry the left’s hostility to the gig economy. A slice:

Seattle’s minimum-wage experience with food delivery offers even clearer causal evidence. A 2025 NBER working paper comparing Seattle delivery workers with those elsewhere in Washington found that the city’s task-level minimum-pay rule doubled average base pay per task. But lower tips erased more than a third of that gain, while highly active workers completed fewer monthly tasks. The result was no increase in their overall monthly earnings.

Unpaid idle time also increased, as did distances driven between tasks. The NBER authors attributed this outcome to free entry into the labor market: higher per-task pay attracted more workers, leaving more of them competing for a limited pool of deliveries. Workers consequently completed fewer tasks and spent more unpaid time waiting between them, offsetting the gains from higher per-task pay.

Humanity survived doomsday!

{ 0 comments }

Quotation of the Day…

… is from page 57 of Thomas Sowell’s 1999 book, Barbarians Inside the Gates:

Neither the public nor the media seem to be aware of how many professional hysteria-mongers there are with a vested interest in exaggerating every remote danger and inventing other dangers out of thin air. Unfortunately, the media’s own vested interest in hype makes it all too willing to amplify whatever hysteria will sell newspapers or get more viewers to watch the tube.

DBx: Yep. Of course today, the venues for hyping hysteria are greater in number than when Sowell’s wrote these words.

And hysteria hyping is done not only by people with venal, material interests; it’s done also to promote ideological crusades. “The middle-class is disappearing!” “We don’t make things anymore!” “Foreigners are stealing our jobs!” “Foreigners are ripping us off!” “Capitalism is destroying the environment!” “Income inequality is destroying democracy!” None of these claims about the U.S. is true, yet they are persistently pronounced, both by people with venal interests in government interventions, as well as by people who are, for one reason or another, ideologically committed to such interventions.

{ 0 comments }

Protectionists Can’t Get Their Stories Straight

Here’s a letter to the Wall Street Journal. (I here overlook the fact that, despite the paper that Greer cites in support of the proposition that foreigners ate most of the tariffs, the bulk of the empirical work on this matter shows the opposite.)

Editor:

Defending the administration’s tariffs, U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer endorses President Trump’s claim that foreign exporters bear much of these tariffs’ burden by lowering the prices they charge Americans (Letters, November 16th).

How odd. Greer repeatedly complains that Americans purchase too many imports. In September 2025, he lamented that “cheap goods flooded our market from countries like China.” In the same speech, he warned that “[o]ur addiction to imports contributes to the indebtedness of our country.” And testifying before Congress in April 2025, Greer insisted that America must stop foreigners from “using us as a dumping ground for their overproduction or their subsidized products.”

Yet Greer now boasts that Trump’s tariffs induce foreigners to lower their prices to Americans. Strange, that. The more foreigners absorb these tariffs by cutting their prices, the more they offset the tariffs’ protective effects, thus undermining the administration’s professed goal of discouraging imports and protecting American producers.

Also, because Greer has repeatedly asserted that foreigners sell goods to Americans at unfairly low prices, it’s peculiar that he now celebrates as a feature of Trump’s tariffs their alleged success at inducing foreigners to lower these already objectionably low prices even further.

Sincerely,
Donald J. Boudreaux
Professor of Economics
and
Martha and Nelson Getchell Chair for the Study of Free Market Capitalism at the Mercatus Center
George Mason University
Fairfax, VA 22030

{ 0 comments }

Some Links

Jacob Sullum describes how cruel and unjust the so-called “war on drugs” can be to people innocent of any serious wrongdoing. Two slices:

Eight years ago, Scott Hancock, then 28, helped a 19-year-old acquaintance, identified in court records as T.G., buy fentanyl. At her request, Hancock, who had been addicted to opioids for years, got in touch with his drug dealer, who gave him five capsules that he handed over to T.G. in exchange for $20. Then Hancock gave the money to his dealer. Because T.G. subsequently died from a fentanyl overdose, Hancock is serving a 20-year sentence at a federal prison in Illinois.

That was the mandatory minimum sentence under 21 USC 241, which prescribes penalties for drug distribution resulting in death. Although that law has been on the books since 1986, the dramatic increase in fentanyl-related deaths during the last decade prompted a surge in federal drug prosecutions involving overdoses, which rose by 44 percent between FY 2019 and FY 2023. Hancock’s case was part of that trend, and it prompted his mother, G.D. Hancock, a retired finance professor, to delve into the subject, resulting in a database that sheds light on what happens when the government treats accidental deaths as homicides.

So far, Hancock has identified 2,930 sentences in such cases since 2010. That includes 1,399 federal cases and 1,531 state cases, which rely either on laws dealing specifically with drug-induced deaths or on more general statutes addressing felony murder, “depraved heart” homicide, or manslaughter.

Sentences of 20 years or more were pretty common at the federal level, accounting for 37 percent of the cases, compared to 13 percent at the state level. The vast majority of the cases (84 percent) were resolved by plea deals. That is not surprising, given the potential consequences of going to trial. While the median sentence for defendants who pleaded guilty was nine years, it was 20 years for defendants who insisted on making the government prove its case.

Hancock’s tally is based on news reports, court records, announcements by state and federal prosecutors, her own “case files and research,” and “cases sent in by families, lawyers and researchers.” A separate database compiled by researchers at Northeastern University, drawn from news reports, includes 3,264 cases involving drug-induced homicide from 2011 to 2022.

These prosecutions are morally nonsensical. They treat people who voluntarily consume drugs as helpless victims of supposed predators who gave them the drugs they wanted. By similar logic, bartenders and liquor store owners should be held criminally liable whenever a customer succumbs to alcohol poisoning or the long-term effects of heavy drinking. The main difference is the legal status of the drug, which is arbitrary, politically determined, and historically contingent. And while illegal drugs pose special hazards, that is a result of prohibition, which creates a black market where product composition is highly variable and unpredictable.

…..

The official justification for these prosecutions is completely disconnected from the reality of the cases. “Deaths from illicit drugs, especially fentanyl, are at historic highs,” the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) said in a 2023 press release. Because the DEA is “committed to protecting Americans and saving lives by pursuing those responsible,” the agency explained, it aims to “make sure as many drug traffickers involved in those deaths as possible get an appearance in front of a judge.”

As an example of that strategy, the DEA cited Scott Hancock’s case, describing him as a “trafficker” who was “found guilty of providing the drugs that killed a 19-year-old woman in 2018.” Given the details of that transaction, it is hard to see the logic here. Sending someone like Hancock to prison for 20 years has nothing to do with “saving lives.”

The Editorial Board of the Washington Post calls for the repeal of the cronyist and economically destructive Jones Act. Two slices:

President Donald Trump made the right call on Friday when he extended a waiver of the Jones Act for 90 days. But the move deserves only two cheers, because the waiver itself has been severely watered down, undermining its effectiveness. The original waiver’s initial benefits to trade were so apparent that the case for scuppering the law itself has never been stronger.

The 106-year-old Jones Act requires goods traveling between U.S. ports to move on vessels that are U.S.-built, U.S.-owned, U.S.-flagged and U.S.-crewed. When war with Iran sent energy prices soaring, the Trump administration broadly relaxed those restrictions in March.

What followed was a successful free-market experiment. Foreign vessels completed hundreds of voyages that otherwise would have been illegal. The White House says the waiver has enabled an additional 90 million barrels of petroleum to move between American ports, including 27 million barrels of gasoline and 26 million barrels of crude oil.
But now government is back in the way. Under pressure from the domestic maritime industry, the Trump administration narrowed the waiver in August, replacing the broad exemption with case-by-case reviews. That bad feature remains in Friday’s extension. Before using a foreign vessel, a shipper must ask the government for permission. The Maritime Administration checks whether an eligible American vessel is available, and the Pentagon decides whether the proposed voyage qualifies.

Traffic slowed to a trickle after that change. Only nine energy cargoes moved on foreign-flagged vessels after Aug. 17 through early October, compared with more than 280 voyages during the preceding five months. “The preclearance process itself is slow and unwieldy,” Bloomberg News reported last month, “and frequent denials have led some companies to abandon pursuing approvals.”

…..

This is crony capitalism on the high seas. When a well-connected industry is taking on water, politicians keep competitors away and make consumers pay to keep it afloat. If an American vessel can move a product more efficiently than a foreign competitor, it should win the business. If it can’t, Washington shouldn’t rig the market in its favor.

Scott Lincicome tweets:

US Steel CEO re the Golden Share:

“The government has not stepped in and told us we can’t do this, we can’t do that.”

Very next sentence:

“We know what the rules are.”

(So, the government doesn’t HAVE to step in.)

Megan McArdle writes insightfully about Jensen Huang and his honeypot downfall. A slice:

In hindsight, his blasé attitude toward California’s recently defeated billionaire wealth tax ballot measure also looks suspicious. Sure, maybe he’s just an altruistic guy. But a tax that would threaten founders’ control of their companies, reduce returns on entrepreneurship and erode the concentration of capital in Silicon Valley sure seems like something the Chinese Communist Party would support.

{ 0 comments }