True Liberals

by Don Boudreaux on January 21, 2010

in History

On page 372 of his posthumously published History of Economic Analysis, Joseph Schumpeter described the 18th- and 19th-century proponents of free markets as putting forth their program

in a spirit of laissez-faire, that is to say, on the theory that the best way to promote economic development and general welfare is to remove fetters from the private-enterprise economy and to leave it alone.  This is what will be meant in this book by Economic Liberalism.  The reader is requested to keep this definition in mind because the term has acquired a different– in fact almost the opposite– meaning since about 1900 and especially since 1930: as a supreme, if unintended, compliment, the enemies of the system of private enterprise have thought it wise to appropriate its label. [emphasis added]

Comments    Share Share    Print Print    Email Email

  • Max
    Well, I hate to say it, but this is mostly a problem of ignorant America. Everywhere else in the world liberal stands for classical liberalism (though as much hated as libertarianism in the US)....
  • What stronger affirmation could there be of the place that real liberalism has earned in the hearts of men than the fact that it can only be attacked by those cunning enough to cloak themselves in it and claim it as their own?

    “…the champions of the abolition of liberty…realized that it was hopeless…to fight openly for…servitude…to attack liberalism…openly…Anti-liberalism’s only chance was to camouflage itself as true liberalism…socialists…were not plagued by any scruples when they stole the good old name of liberalism…nowadays more often than not…a synonym for communism.” Mises

    And they are most aggrieved that we do not see them as the liberals and progressives that they pretend to be, but as the communists they really are..

    Our calling them communists is certainly no worse than their calling themselves liberals. But I'll make a deal with them. They stop calling themselves liberals and I'll stop calling them communists.
  • Schumpeter was a weeeeeeird dude...
  • Curious
    The main reason for laissez-faire capitalism is not promoting economic development and general welfare (whatever that means).

    The main reason for laissez-faire capitalism is the fact that it means freedom. Or better yet, it is freedom.
  • Methinks1776
    The United State is no longer considered to have a free economy. Welcome to sociofascism, folks.

    http://www.heritage.org/index/Ranking.aspx
  • vidyohs
    Maybe it is just me to think this way, but I notice that the individual states of the European Union are listed separately while they became unified under EU rules and laws last year.

    How is Ireland listed as more free than England when both are EU states now?

    Yet the individual states of the USA are not listed separately. Would that make a difference if Texas was separated out and examined as an individual entity?

    Makes me curious.
  • Methinks1776
    Good question. I'm under the impression that the EU is much weaker in governing member states than the U.S. Federal government is in governing individual American states.

    For one thing, each country sees itself as a separate entity much more than American states see themselves as separate from each other.
  • CRC
    I was waiting to see what would happen with the 2010 ranking. I'm not surprised. Still in the top 10, but dropping. Sad.
  • Gil
    Where to now then?
  • Methinks1776
    Hong Kong.
  • Or Australia.
  • My wife keeps talking about moving to Australia. Is it really any better?
  • Sorry, sorry, just kidding,

    You shouldn’t shoot anyone, ever, unless you’re ccw, or have licensed US training, or know how to hunt for food, or know things like how to survive on the land, or how to be productive, or how to do stuff, or things.

    Signed,

    The Banks are taking far too much risk, trading things like commercial paper, sharp edges, and paper clips.
  • Methinks1776
    LOL!

    I know you can't smoke weed or litter there, but I still like Singapore.
  • Go find out for yourself, mate.

    There are more things in Oz that can kill you than anywhere else in the whirled.
  • A bit, mate.

    Most of it's uninhabited, and the rest you can shoot!

    [Unwarranted endorsement from the NSW Tourist Board]
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: