… is from page 243 of David Schmidtz’s wisdom-packed 2023 book, Living Together [original emphasis]:
The highest political standards are not the ones we personally find most appealing. Rather, truly having reason to embrace anything as a political ideal starts by observing that conflict resolution is an exercise in the art of compromise. A politically ideal community is habitable partly because no one’s moral ideal ever sweeps the field.
DBx: Yes.
To accompany this quotation I chose a photograph of my late Nobel-laureate colleague, James Buchanan, because – contrary to much uninformed commentary about Buchanan – what Dave Schmidtz writes here captures nicely a principle that was always core to Buchanan’s political philosophy, and one that he expressed quite directly on countless occasions.


The highest political standards are not the ones we personally find most appealing. Rather, truly having reason to embrace anything as a political ideal starts by observing that conflict resolution is an exercise in the art of compromise. A politically ideal community is habitable partly because no one’s moral ideal ever sweeps the field.
